What hardness (durometer) should my gasket, grip, seal or keypad be? Pick the application, the feel you want and how much the part has to deflect or hold under load. The selector returns a representative Shore A hardness range for that job, tells you where to aim within it, and lays out the trade-off: softer rubber seals and conforms better but sets and wears faster; harder rubber lasts and holds its shape but seals less and feels stiffer.

Engineering estimate, not a quote. The final durometer is set with the compound family, the gland or seat geometry, the surface it works against and a confirmed sample.
Durometer is the first number anyone asks for on a rubber or silicone part, and the one most often guessed. This selector does not guess. It uses the way the part works โ seal, grip, keypad, mount, wheel or O-ring โ to pick the Shore A band that real parts in that job tend to live in, then uses your deflection answer to tell you where in the band to aim and what to prove on a sample. The bands come from common molding and seal-design practice, so treat every number here as representative, hedged, and subject to a real test, not as a specification.
What Shore A measures. Shore A durometer runs 0–100 and comes from a spring-loaded indenter pressed into the rubber: the less it sinks in, the higher the number. Shore A 20 is a soft, gel-like rubber; A 50 is close to a pencil eraser; A 70 is a typical O-ring or shoe sole; A 90 is a hard caster tyre. Above roughly A 90 the Shore A scale loses resolution and the harder Shore D scale takes over, which is why wheels and rollers are often quoted part-way into Shore D. The one thing to keep in mind is that durometer is only surface hardness. It says nothing directly about tensile strength, tear resistance, compression set or service life โ two compounds at the same A 60 can wear and relax very differently.
Why the application sets the band. Each kind of part has a job that pulls it toward soft or hard. A seal has to conform to the face it presses on, so it lives soft, A 20–40 for a light dust seal and A 40–60 for a general gasket, rising to A 60–80 only when high clamp load or pressure would otherwise push a soft rubber into the gap. A grip or handle wants give without feeling spongy, which lands around A 40–60. A keypad or button needs a repeatable, pleasant click, again about A 40–60: softer gives a lighter, mushier touch and harder gives a crisper, higher-force one. A vibration mount or bushing is tuned by hardness because a softer rubber isolates more but sags more under the same load, so these sit A 40–80 depending on the weight they carry. An O-ring defaults to A 70 and moves to A 90 for high pressure or large clearance. A load-bearing wheel or roller is hard, A 80 up into Shore D, so it carries weight without crushing or overheating.
The soft-versus-hard trade. Nearly every durometer decision is the same trade. Softer rubber conforms to rough and out-of-flat surfaces, seals at a lower closing force, grips better and cushions more. In exchange it takes more compression set, tears more easily, drags more when something slides against it and wears out sooner. Harder rubber is the mirror image: it holds its shape under load and torque, resists extrusion and abrasion and lasts longer, but it seals a rough face less reliably, transmits more shock and feels stiff. The engineering answer is almost never the softest or the hardest available โ it is the softest durometer that still resists extrusion and recovers over the life of the part, or the hardest that still seals and feels right.
Three parts, three answers, computed the way the selector computes them. Press Load the worked example above to reproduce the first one.
Notice that the deflection answer never moves the band โ it tells you where to aim inside it and what to prove. A soft seal aimed at A 25 still lives in the A 20–40 seal band; the caster aimed hard still lives in the wheel band that runs from A 85 into Shore D.
| Application | Soft feel | Medium feel | Firm feel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seal / gasket | A 20โ40 | A 40โ60 | A 60โ80 |
| Grip / handle | A 30โ50 | A 40โ60 | A 55โ75 |
| Keypad / button | A 30โ50 | A 40โ60 | A 55โ70 |
| Vibration mount / bushing | A 40โ60 | A 60โ80 | A 75โ90 |
| Wheel / roller | A 80โ90 | A 85 โ Shore D | A 95 โ Shore D |
| O-ring | A 50โ65 | A 65โ80 | A 80โ90 |
Sources for the method. Shore A and Shore D durometer are defined by ASTM D2240 and ISO 7619 (hardness of rubber by indentation). The application bands are representative values from common rubber-molding and seal-design practice as published in elastomer and O-ring design guides; the O-ring defaults (A 70 standard, A 90 for high pressure or large clearance) follow standard gland-design guidance. These are starting points for discussion, not a datasheet: the compound you choose, its cure, the operating temperature and the mating surface all move the real answer, which is why the final durometer is always confirmed on a sample.
For any part that lives under constant squeeze โ a static gasket, an O-ring, a bushing, a soft foot โ the durometer barely matters once the part has relaxed. What matters is compression set: how much permanent deformation the rubber keeps after being held compressed. A seal keeps sealing only while it still pushes back on the face, and a compound that takes a large set stops pushing back and leaks, no matter how soft or hard it started. Softer rubber and higher service temperature generally raise the set, so a soft seal that works on assembly day can fail months later. Silicone usually has better compression-set behaviour than most thermoplastic elastomers, which is one reason it dominates long-life gaskets and seals. When you specify a durometer for a static seal, specify the compression-set requirement in the same breath, because the hardness alone will not get you a seal that lasts.
The durometer band is only half the specification; the compound family is the other half, and the two are chosen together. Liquid silicone rubber (LSR) is a thermoset silicone injection-moulded in high volume for small precision parts โ seals, valves, keypads, baby and medical-style parts โ covering roughly Shore A 10–80. High-consistency (gum) silicone, HCR, is a thermoset silicone usually compression, transfer or extrusion processed for larger parts, profiles and tubing, over a similar hardness range. Thermoplastic elastomers (TPE, TPV, TPU) are melt-processed like ordinary plastic, are recyclable, bond easily when over-moulded onto a rigid substrate, and span the widest hardness range of all, from soft gels through the whole Shore A scale and into Shore D for stiff parts such as wheels and skate frames. Silicone holds its properties over a far wider temperature range and generally sets less; TPE is often easier and cheaper to process and over-mould. For this selector, the durometer band applies to whichever family you pick โ you choose the hardness for the job, then the family for the temperature, chemical exposure, over-moulding and volume.
Durometer and surface finish together decide how a part feels and how it slides. A soft rubber with a glossy, low-finish mould surface feels grippy and even tacky, and drags hard against anything sliding on it; the same durometer with a matte or textured finish feels drier and slides more freely. For a grip you often want a soft durometer with a slight texture so it is secure without being sticky. For a dynamic seal or a sliding button you usually want a smoother, sometimes coated or self-lubricating surface so the soft rubber does not stick and stutter. Specifying the mould finish (for example an SPI or VDI texture) alongside the durometer is what turns a hardness number into the feel you actually wanted. The silicone and rubber parts guide covers the finish and compound choices that ride along with the hardness.
| Method | Use it when | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| This selector | Choosing a starting durometer at concept stage; explaining why a part feels or seals the way it does | Representative bands only; does not size a gland, rate a load or pick a compound |
| O-ring / gland design guide | Any pressurised or dynamic O-ring seal | Needs the gland geometry, pressure and clearance |
| Compound datasheet | Final specification in a named grade | Per grade; you still choose the target hardness |
| Compression-set and aging tests | Long-life static seals and gaskets | Needs samples and time at temperature |
| Moulded sample / prototype | Confirming feel, click, seal and fit before tooling | The real answer โ everything above only narrows it down |
Reviewed by the JCH tooling team ยท updated November 2026
For most general gaskets and face seals, a representative starting point is Shore A 40–60. Softer, in the A 20–40 band, seals better against a rough or warped surface and needs less closing force, which suits dust seals, skins and lids. Firmer, A 60–80, holds its shape under higher clamp load and bolt torque and resists extrusion into gaps, which suits flange and bulkhead seals. The exact point depends on the surface it seals against, the gland depth and the squeeze you can apply. Treat these as representative ranges, not fixed values; the final choice is confirmed on a sample.
Shore A durometer is a hardness number from 0 to 100 that comes from pressing a standard spring-loaded indenter into the rubber and reading how far it fails to sink in. A low number such as 20 is a very soft, gel-like rubber; 50 is like a pencil eraser; 70 is a typical O-ring or shoe sole; 90 is a hard caster tyre. It is a measure of surface hardness and resistance to indentation, not of tensile strength, tear strength or service life. Two compounds at the same durometer can behave very differently in wear, compression set and chemical resistance.
Usually yes, up to a point. A softer rubber conforms to the mating surface and fills its scratches and waviness at a lower closing force, so it seals a rough or slightly out-of-flat face more reliably. The trade-off is that softer rubber generally takes more compression set (it stays squashed), tears more easily, drags more against sliding surfaces and wears faster. The practical answer is to use the softest durometer that still resists extrusion into the gap and recovers acceptably over the life of the part, rather than the softest available.
Compression set is the permanent deformation a rubber keeps after it has been held compressed and then released: a gasket squeezed 25% that only springs back part way has taken a set. It matters because a seal keeps sealing only while it still pushes back on the mating face. Softer compounds and higher temperatures generally increase set, so a soft seal that works on day one can relax and leak later. For a part under constant compression โ a static gasket, an O-ring, a bushing โ compression-set resistance often matters more than the durometer number, and the compound and cure, not just the hardness, control it.
Liquid silicone rubber (LSR) and high-consistency silicone rubber (HCR, or gum silicone) are both thermoset silicones covering roughly Shore A 10–80; LSR is injection-moulded for high-volume small parts such as seals, valves and keypads, while HCR is often compression or transfer moulded for larger or extruded parts. Thermoplastic elastomers (TPE and TPU) are melt-processed like ordinary plastic, recyclable, and span a very wide range from soft gels through Shore A into the Shore D scale for stiff parts such as wheels. Silicone holds its properties over a wider temperature range and tends to set less; TPE can be cheaper to process and easier to over-mould onto a rigid substrate. The bands on this page apply to any of them; the family is chosen alongside the hardness.
The most common O-ring hardness is Shore A 70, with Shore A 90 used where the pressure is high and the clearance gap is larger, to resist the ring being extruded into that gap, and A 60 or lower used for low-pressure or vacuum seals that need to conform. A 70 is the usual default because it balances easy assembly and good sealing against reasonable extrusion resistance. The gland design and the system pressure drive the choice more than feel does.
Load-bearing wheels and rollers are hard: representatively from about Shore A 80 up into the Shore D scale (roughly Shore D 45–60 for hard industrial casters). Harder wheels roll with less effort and carry more load with less deflection and heat build-up, but they transmit more shock and grip less. Softer tread, down toward Shore A 70, is quieter, kinder to delicate floors and grips better, at the cost of load capacity and rolling resistance. A roller that must drive or pinch a web is chosen for grip and is often softer than a wheel that only carries weight.
Not reliably if it is too thin. The Shore A test assumes the specimen is at least about 6 mm (0.25 in) thick, or several layers stacked to that thickness, so the indenter reads the rubber and not the hard surface underneath. On a thin seal lip, a keypad web or a coating, a reading taken directly on the part is usually too high and inconsistent. For thin sections, measure a thicker tab moulded in the same compound, or use an instrument intended for thin material, and always state the thickness the reading was taken on.
Not sure whether to go softer for the seal or harder for the wear? Ask our AI assistant. It answers from this website, and our tooling team follows up if you want.
AI assistant. Answers can be wrong; nothing it says is a quote or a promise.
This selector gives an engineering estimate. Our vetted tooling network moulds a short step kit in two or three hardnesses so you can feel the seal, grip or click in your hand, then locks the durometer and compression-set spec before the steel is cut.
Book a 30-min call Send a drawing or sample