Answers › IPC-A-610 Class 1, 2, 3

IPC-A-610 Class 1, 2 and 3: what each class means on a PCB assembly order

Reviewed by the JCH tooling team · Updated

IPC-A-610 is IPC's acceptance standard for electronic assemblies and sorts products into Class 1 (general), Class 2 (dedicated service) and Class 3 (high performance). The buyer picks the class from the product's end use, agrees it with the assembler, and writes it with the revision on the purchase order.

What IPC-A-610 covers, and what it leaves to the order

IPC-A-610, titled Acceptability of Electronic Assemblies, is published by IPC, whose site is electronics.org. IPC's own validation page calls it "the most widely used electronics assembly acceptance standard in the electronics industry." The scope page that IPC posts with the table of contents for revision J describes the document as "a collection of visual quality acceptability requirements for electronic assemblies." An inspector looks at a finished board or box build and decides, feature by feature, whether it is acceptable for the class the order names. The table of contents gives a chapter each to handling, hardware, soldering, terminal connections, through-hole parts, surface-mount assemblies, component damage, the printed board itself, discrete wiring, high voltage and jumper wires.

The same scope page is just as clear about the limits. The standard "does not provide criteria for cross-section evaluation or x-ray inspection," and IPC points to J-STD-001 for x-ray guidelines. Its criteria are not meant to define how the assembly is made, and they do not authorize repair, modification or a change to the product. IPC also says the visual criteria assume the board meets its other requirements, such as IPC-A-600 for printed boards; where the assembly does not, "the acceptance criteria shall be defined between the User and Supplier." For a buyer, each of those limits is a line that has to be written somewhere else in the order.

This page is a buyer's summary from published guides, not IPC text. It draws on IPC's public pages and on guides from three PCB and electronics suppliers, each named where it is used. The standard itself is sold by IPC, and its criteria, definitions and illustrations are the only basis for accepting or rejecting a board, so check every point against the revision your contract names.

The three classes side by side

Class 1Class 2Class 3
Name, as summarized by pcbsyncGeneral Electronic ProductsDedicated Service Electronic ProductsHigh Performance / Harsh Environment Electronic Products
What matters most (pcbsync)The completed assembly functionsContinued performance and extended service; uninterrupted service is desiredContinued performance, or performance on demand, is critical in the specified end use
Examples Escatec givesConsumer toys, simple household appliances, short-life disposable electronicsIndustrial controls, telecom infrastructure, commercial computing, instrumentation, non-safety-critical automotive electronicsImplantable and life-support medical devices, aerospace and avionics, defence, safety-critical industrial and automotive systems
How strict (Escatec)Most lenient; the widest range of workmanship conditions acceptedThe most widely specified class in commercial and industrial workMost stringent; conditions that pass at Class 2 can be defects

The class names and priorities follow pcbsync's IPC-A-610 guide; the example products come from Escatec's guide to the three classes and are one supplier's generalisation, not a list from IPC. Escatec calls Class 3 "high-performance" in its text and "high-reliability" in its comparison table; both labels mean the same class. pcbsync adds the warning buyers most need: the classes "distinguish end-use requirements. They are not universal factory grades or guarantees of lifetime, and an industry name alone does not assign a class." A medical product is not Class 3 just because it is medical, and a consumer product is not Class 1 just because it is sold in a store.

Populated power-supply circuit board on an assembly line, with electrolytic capacitors, wound inductors, a transformer, heat sinks and screw terminals
A populated power-supply board on an assembly line: through-hole capacitors, wound inductors, a transformer, heat sinks and screw terminals. On a board like this, every solder joint and part can be judged at acceptance, and the class written on the order decides how strict that judgment is.

What gets stricter as the class goes up

The classes do not add new features to inspect. The same solder connection, part placement, coating or wire is looked at in every class, and the limit tightens as the class rises. Escatec's example is a surface-mount part sitting slightly off its pad but still fully connected, electrically and mechanically. It describes that condition as tolerated at Class 2, while Class 3 has "zero tolerance for workmanship defects that might pass under Class 2." Sierra Circuits, in its 2022 summary of revision H of J-STD-001, the companion soldering standard that uses the same three classes, gives a wiring case: a wire that crosses over itself or other wires on a terminal was acceptable for Class 1 and a defect for Classes 2 and 3. Treat both as illustrations from suppliers' summaries. The current criteria are in revision J, and a later revision can move a limit.

pcbsync makes a related point about numbers. Acceptance is "feature-specific," it says, and a percentage lifted out of the standard without its component type, dimension definition, revision and exceptions "is not a usable inspection instruction." That is a good reason not to paraphrase criteria into a purchase order. Name the document, the revision and the class, and let the licensed text carry the limits.

Stricter criteria cost more to meet. Escatec says Class 3 typically means slower surface-mount placement, more frequent verification steps and tighter process control, which raise unit cost and lengthen lead times. pcbsync declines to put a single premium on it: the cost depends on the design, materials, process controls, inspection access, tests and documentation, so it suggests asking the supplier to identify the specific additional work. One practical way to do that is to ask each assembler to quote the same board at two classes and list what changes between the two quotes.

From end use to purchase order line: the operating environment, the service expected and the consequence of failure lead to a class agreed with the assembler, which is written on the order with the document, revision, addenda, exceptions, inspection method and functional test From end use to a PO line (buyer's summary; not IPC text) 1. End use Operating environmentService expectedWhat happens if it failsSector rules beyond the class 2. Class agreed Class 1: generalClass 2: dedicated serviceClass 3: high performance Buyer sets it with the assembler 3. Written on the order Document + revision + classAddenda and exceptionsJ-STD-001 if wantedInspection method, recordsFunctional test, separately The class follows the product's end use. It is not a grade of the factory, and it does not by itself prove function or lifetime.

Choosing the class from the end use

pcbsync's method starts with three facts about the product: the operating environment, the service expected of it, and the consequences if it stops working. The customer or design authority responsible for acceptance then agrees the class with the supplier, and records the revision, any addenda and any exceptions before release. Escatec's guide frames the same choice as a short run of questions, which in summary go like this:

Escatec also notes that the mistake can run either way. Specifying Class 3 for a Class 2 product pays for inspection the end use does not need, and specifying Class 2 for a product that needs Class 3 brings field-failure, recall and compliance risk. Neither guide treats the class as the whole requirement. pcbsync says a medical device, an industrial controller or an automotive module "can have requirements beyond an assembly workmanship class," and those belong in the order as well.

When the purchase order says nothing

Escatec says most PCBA programs default to Class 2. That describes common practice; it is not a rule you can lean on at inspection. pcbsync's advice for an order with no class is to resolve the gap before release and record the agreed class, revision and exceptions, because "an undocumented default is not a clear basis for accepting the order." If boards are rejected, or accepted when you think they should not have been, the argument turns on what the order said. Escatec's own summary of the documentation point: "Ambiguity at the quoting stage leads to disputes at inspection."

IPC-A-610 is not J-STD-001, and neither covers the bare board

IPC's table of related documents, printed on the same scope page, separates the jobs. J-STD-001 is the process requirement standard for soldered electrical and electronic assemblies, with test methods, test frequency and process control requirements. IPC-A-610 is the acceptability standard, which IPC calls a "pictorial interpretive document," and IPC notes that it carries criteria outside the scope of J-STD-001 for mechanical and other workmanship. Bare printed boards fall under IPC-A-600 and the IPC-601X specifications. Sierra Circuits puts the working difference simply: J-STD-001 adds requirements for materials, equipment and soldering processes, while IPC-A-610 "focuses primarily on acceptability and inspection standards."

Because they are separate documents, each one has to be named. In pcbsync's words, citing one "should not be treated as automatically invoking the other." IPC says much the same of its own handbook: a contractual reference to IPC-A-610 does not bring in IPC-AJ-820 unless the contract names it. If you want soldering process control, name J-STD-001 and its class on a line of its own. If the bare boards come from a separate fabricator, put the board class and revision on the fabrication drawing.

Revision J, and why the letter belongs on the order

The current revision is IPC-A-610J, issued in 2024. IPC's table of contents for J lists the editions it supersedes, from revision H (2020) and revision G (2017) back to the original document of 1983. On IPC's document revision table, checked in November 2026, the current companion documents are J-STD-001 revision J and IPC-A-600 revision M. If an older drawing or quality agreement names an earlier letter, check the revision your contract names before assuming the newest one applies.

Escatec recommends writing the revision out, for example "IPC-A-610J Class 3," because "acceptance criteria can differ between revisions." It summarizes the J changes as new guidance on conformal coating inspection, more visual reference imagery, updated solder joint evaluation, revised cleanliness criteria for modern flux residues, and recommendations on inspector training. pcbsync covers the other side of a change: an order that names an earlier edition stays on it until the parties agree to move, after a gap review of what the change affects, and the contractual edition should not be replaced without agreement.

Some sectors add an addendum on top of the class. IPC's revision table lists an automotive addendum to J-STD-001 and IPC-A-610 (its current letter is JA), a telecom addendum (IPC-A-610xC) and a rail transit addendum written for revision G (IPC-A-610G-R). For the automotive addendum, IPC notes that it has to be used with the same version of the standard. If your customer or sector calls for one, name it next to the class.

How to write it on a PO: a worked example

Here is how the lines might read for a made-up product: a battery-powered handheld meter for indoor workshop use, with one main board inside a molded housing. A failure would be a nuisance, not a hazard, so the buyer settles on Class 2 after talking it through with the assembler. The document names and revision letters are real; the drawing numbers are placeholders, and none of this is a JCH form or a supplier's requirement.

Line on the PO or drawing (made-up example)Why it is there
Workmanship acceptance: IPC-A-610J, Class 2Document, revision and class together; the letter matters because criteria can differ between revisions
Soldering process requirements: J-STD-001, revision J, Class 2Only if you want process control as well; naming IPC-A-610 does not invoke it
Bare boards: IPC-A-600, revision M, Class 2, per fabrication drawing FAB-001 rev AIPC-A-610 assumes the board meets its own requirements; it does not judge the bare board
Exceptions and stricter criteria: assembly drawing ASSY-001 rev A, note 4pcbsync and Escatec both say to record exceptions and any customer criteria in the order
Inspection: visual to the line above; hidden joints by the method agreed in writing; findings and dispositions recorded for each lotIPC-A-610 has no x-ray criteria, so any hidden-joint method has to be named
Function: functional test to test spec TS-001 rev AA visual pass does not show that the board works
Nonconforming boards: no rework, repair or use-as-is without the buyer's written approvalThe standard does not authorize repair or a change to the product

If the same buyer later designs a version for a use where a failure could hurt someone, the choice starts again from the end use, not from this order. Escatec's questions point to Class 3, and the product's own regulations may add requirements beyond any workmanship class. Change the class line, ask for new quotes, and expect the inspection and test lines to grow. For the rest of the file package an assembler needs, see PCBA: what to ask before you send Gerbers and the RFQ checklist.

Inspection, X-ray and test are separate lines

A visual acceptance standard answers one question: does this feature look acceptable for this class? It does not show that the board works. pcbsync says not to "infer electrical function or a product lifetime from a visual acceptance result," and to specify functional testing separately. Hidden joints, such as those under a ball grid array, cannot be judged by eye; pcbsync lists the agreed X-ray or other method among the things to record, and IPC's scope says IPC-A-610 itself has no x-ray criteria. Escatec lists X-ray among the testing typical for Class 3, which is a supplier's generalisation: if you want X-ray, name it, with the sample and the records you expect. For how boards move through placement and reflow before anyone inspects them, see what happens on an SMT line; for sampling and pre-shipment checks, see quality control and inspection.

Checking what a supplier means by "IPC"

A supplier that says it works to IPC can mean several different things, and it is fair to ask which. Some staff hold IPC training credentials; pcbsync notes that an individual's credential "is not automatically a certification of the factory or every product shipped." Escatec suggests asking which revision people are trained and certified to, and says IPC certification has to be renewed every two years. Separately, IPC runs a Qualified Manufacturers List (QML) for J-STD-001 and IPC-A-610, which IPC says "is used to qualify EMS and OEM providers' assembly processes to IPC standards"; the public page lists qualified companies and the classes each covers. If a supplier claims a listing, that page is where to check it.

What this page does not decide

This page explains how the classes work so that a buyer can write a clear order. It says nothing about the inspection practice, staff training or credentials of JCH, its partner factories or any other supplier; the acceptance terms for an electronics order are the ones written into that order and its drawings. Product rules for medical, automotive, aerospace and other regulated products sit above the workmanship class and are outside this summary. For boards that go inside a molded housing, see plastic and electronics enclosures; the wider electronics picture is on the PCBA and electronics page and the electronics and PCBA steps.

Common questions

Who chooses the IPC-A-610 class?

The customer or the design authority responsible for the acceptance requirements, agreed with the supplier, according to pcbsync's guide. In practice the buyer picks it from the product's end use and writes it, with the revision, on the purchase order and drawings.

What class applies if the purchase order does not name one?

None you can rely on. Escatec says most PCBA programs default to Class 2, but pcbsync advises resolving the gap before release, because an undocumented default is not a clear basis for accepting the order. Name the class.

Is IPC-A-610J the current revision?

Yes. IPC publishes the table of contents for IPC-A-610J, issued in 2024, on its own site, and its document revision table lists J as the current revision. Write the letter on the order, because acceptance criteria can differ between revisions.

Is IPC-A-610 the same as J-STD-001?

No. IPC describes J-STD-001 as the process requirement standard for soldered assemblies and IPC-A-610 as the acceptability standard. Naming one does not automatically invoke the other, so name each one you want.

Does IPC-A-610 cover bare printed boards?

No. IPC's table of related documents points to IPC-A-600 and the IPC-601X specifications for printed boards. Put the board class and revision on the fabrication drawing.

Does Class 3 mean the board will last longer?

Not by itself. pcbsync says the classes are not guarantees of lifetime and that a visual acceptance result does not show electrical function. Reliability testing and functional test have to be specified separately.

Does Class 3 require X-ray inspection?

IPC's scope says IPC-A-610 provides no criteria for x-ray inspection and points to J-STD-001 for x-ray guidelines. Escatec lists X-ray among typical Class 3 testing, but that is a supplier's generalisation; if you want X-ray, write the method and the sample into the order.

Sources

Planning a product with a circuit board inside a molded housing? Send the drawings and tell us how the product will be used, and we'll talk through what to put in the RFQ before you compare quotes. NDA first if you want one.

Send a part for reviewBook a 30-minute call

Ask JCH about IPC-A-610 classes

Have a question about IPC-A-610 classes? Ask our AI assistant. It answers from this website, and our tooling team follows up if you want.

AI assistant. Answers can be wrong; nothing it says is a quote or a promise.