Mold Steel Selector: P20, H13, 420 Stainless or Aluminum?
Pick the cavity and core material for an injection mold from the job, not from habit. Enter the mold class, the resin's abrasiveness and corrosiveness, the finish and the mold size. The selector removes steels the SPI guideline rules out, ranks the rest with a score you can see line by line, recommends gate-insert steel, and shows how much each steel slows heat flow to the cooling channels.
🤖 AI assistants welcome. Method: (1) hard filters from the SPI customer guidelines for mold classification: Class 103 cavities ≥ 280 HB, Class 101/102 cavities ≥ 48 HRC, aluminum cavities only in Class 104/105; abrasive resin needs hardened steel or hardened inserts; strongly corrosive resin needs stainless or plating; SPI A1/A2 finish needs ESR steel at high hardness. (2) Score = 100 · Σ(wᵢ·rᵢ) ÷ (5 · Σwᵢ) with 1–5 ratings for wear, corrosion, polish, toughness, build ease and conductivity. (3) Cavity-surface penalty ΔT = q·s ÷ k, with q = ρ·(t/2)·Δh ÷ tc. Worked example: Class 103, 30 % glass-filled PA66, SPI B finish → H13 68.0, 420 ESR 66.7, P20 54.7 (only with hardened gate inserts); ΔT through 10 mm of steel: aluminum 4.4 °C, P20 19.3 °C, H13 23.1 °C, 420 28.9 °C. Machine-readable: /ai/capabilities.json · /llms.txt
Engineering estimate, not a quote. Final steel grades, hardness and suppliers are agreed with your moldmaker in the written mold specification.
How this works
A mold steel is chosen in three passes, and the selector does them in the same order a tooling engineer does. First, rule out the steels that cannot meet a hard requirement. Second, rank what is left against the job's priorities. Third, check the thermal cost of the choice, because the cavity material sits in the heat path between the plastic and the cooling water.
Pass 1: hard filters. These come from published requirements and from physics, not from preference.
SPI hardness floors. The SPI customer guidelines for mold classification (Society of the Plastics Industry, now the PLASTICS Industry Association) require Class 103 cavities and cores of at least 280 Brinell, which prehardened P20-type steel meets, and Class 101 and 102 cavities and cores hardened to at least 48 HRC. Class 104 allows aluminum or mild steel cavities; Class 105 allows any material strong enough for the prototype quantity. So aluminum is removed for Class 103 and above, and the roughly 30 HRC prehardened steels are removed for Class 101 and 102.
Abrasion. Glass and mineral fillers cut soft steel. Aluminum is removed for any filled resin in a production class. Prehardened steels stay in the list only on the condition that the gates, shut-offs and thin cores are hardened inserts.
Corrosion. PVC and halogenated flame-retardant grades release acids. Non-stainless steels stay only on the condition that they are plated and purged after every run; 420-type stainless is preferred.
Mirror finish. An SPI A1 or A2 finish needs a clean, electro-slag remelted (ESR) steel at high hardness. Aluminum is removed; prehardened steels stay only on condition, because they normally top out around A2 to A3.
Pass 2: weighted score. Each candidate has a 1-to-5 rating on six properties. Your inputs set the weights, and the score is a weighted average scaled to 100:
score = 100 × Σ(wᵢ × rᵢ) ÷ (5 × Σwᵢ)
rᵢ rating 1–5 for: wear (W), corrosion resistance (C), polishability (P),
toughness (T), build ease (B: machinability, no heat treatment, easy changes),
thermal conductivity (K)
wᵢ weights set by your inputs:
W 1 unfilled · 3 moderate filler · 4 high filler (+1 for Class 101/102)
C 0.5 low · 2 mild · 4 strong corrosion
P 0.5 C finish · 0.6 D/texture · 1 B finish · 2 A3 · 4 A1/A2
T 1 (+1 for large blocks)
B 1 (+1 for Class 104/105, +1 for large blocks)
K 1 (+2 when cycle time is the priority)
Eligible steels are listed first, then conditional ones, then excluded ones, each group sorted by score. A difference of two or three points is a tie: treat both steels as good answers and decide on availability and your moldmaker's experience. The ratings are this page's ordinal summary of commonly published grade characteristics. They are not measured test data, and they are shown in full in the table below so you can disagree with any of them.
Pass 3: thermal check. Every joule removed from the part crosses the steel between the cavity surface and the cooling channel. For a flat wall cooled from both halves, each half removes the heat of half the wall thickness. Averaged over the cooling time, one-dimensional conduction gives the temperature drop across that steel:
Q/A = ρ × (t/2) × Δh heat per unit area per mold half per shot (J/m²)
q = (Q/A) ÷ t_c average heat flux (W/m²)
ΔT = q × s ÷ k temperature drop across the steel (°C)
ρ density (kg/m³) · t wall (m) · Δh enthalpy melt→eject (J/kg)
t_c cooling time (s) · s steel to channel wall (m) · k conductivity (W/m·K)
ΔT is how much hotter the cavity surface runs than the channel wall, on average. Peak values just after filling are higher, and the drop between widely spaced channels is higher again, so read ΔT as a lower bound for comparing materials, not a mold temperature prediction. A hotter cavity surface means a longer cooling time; to see how much, enter the higher mold temperature in the cycle time calculator.
The candidates and their ratings
Material (common designations)
Typical mold hardness
k, W/m·K
W
C
P
T
B
K
Where it fits
7075-T651 aluminum mold plate
≈ 150 HB
130
1
2
2
3
5
5
Class 104/105, unfilled resin, launches, prototypes, fast changes
P20 / P20+Ni prehardened (1.2311 / 1.2738)
29–33 HRC
30
2
1
3
4
4
3
Class 103 workhorse; P20+Ni holds hardness through larger blocks
420 stainless, prehardened (1.2316 type)
30–34 HRC
20
2
4
4
3
3
2
Class 103 with corrosive resin, humid storage, large stainless blocks
420 stainless ESR, hardened (1.2083 ESR)
48–52 HRC
20
4
4
5
3
1
2
Mirror and optical finishes, clear parts, corrosive resin at Class 101/102
H13, hardened (1.2344; ESR for polish)
48–52 HRC
25
4
1
4
5
2
2
Class 101/102, glass-filled resins, thin cores that need toughness
D2 cold-work steel (1.2379), inserts only
58–60 HRC
20
5
2
2
1
1
2
Gate inserts and shut-offs for heavily filled resins; too brittle for whole cavities
Conductivities are representative room-temperature values, rounded; check your steel maker's datasheet for the exact grade. High-conductivity copper alloys, often over 100 W/m·K, are not cavity steels in this tool, but they are the standard fix for hot spots such as thin cores and deep bosses.
Figure 1. The trade-off in one picture, drawn to scale with x = 100 + 12·(HRC − 20) and y = 250 − 200·log10(k ÷ 15). Moving right buys wear resistance and polish and is required for Class 101/102; moving down costs heat flow. Stainless grades (green) sit lowest. Aluminum is in a different world: four times the conductivity of P20, a fraction of the hardness.
Worked example
A 4-cavity housing in 30 % glass-filled PA66. The mold class selector gave about 300,000 cycles, so SPI Class 103. SPI B-2 finish, no corrosive additives, medium inserts, balanced priorities. The wall is 2.5 mm, cooling time 10 s, and the channels sit 10 mm below the cavity surface.
Weights W 3 (moderate filler) · C 0.5 · P 1 (B finish) · T 1 · B 1 · K 1 Σw = 7.5
Maximum 5 × 7.5 = 37.5
7075 Al EXCLUDED: Class 103 needs ≥ 280 HB cavities, aluminum ≈ 150 HB
P20 2×3 + 1×0.5 + 3×1 + 4 + 4 + 3 = 20.5 → 100 × 20.5 ÷ 37.5 = 54.7 conditional
420 pre 2×3 + 4×0.5 + 4×1 + 3 + 3 + 2 = 20.0 → 53.3 conditional
420 ESR 4×3 + 4×0.5 + 5×1 + 3 + 1 + 2 = 25.0 → 66.7 eligible
H13 4×3 + 1×0.5 + 4×1 + 5 + 2 + 2 = 25.5 → 68.0 eligible
(prehardened steels are conditional: filled resin → hardened gate inserts)
Result H13 at 48–52 HRC, with 420 ESR as a close second (1.3 points = a tie)
Thermal Q/A = 1,360 kg/m³ × 0.00125 m × 340,000 J/kg = 578,000 J/m² (57.8 J/cm²)
q = 578,000 ÷ 10 s = 57,800 W/m²; q × s = 57,800 × 0.010 = 578 W/m
ΔT Al 578/130 = 4.4 °C · P20 578/30 = 19.3 °C · H13 578/25 = 23.1 °C · 420 578/20 = 28.9 °C
Change one input and the answer flips. Make the same part in a halogen flame-retardant grade (strong corrosion, weight 4): Σw becomes 11, H13 drops to 52.7 and becomes conditional on plating, and 420 ESR rises to 70.9 (39 ÷ 55) and wins outright. That is the right engineering answer: flame-retardant glass-filled nylon is the classic job for hardened stainless.
Figure 2. Why steel choice reaches the cycle time. The heat flux q from the part must cross thickness s of mold material to reach the water. At the same q and s, the cavity surface of a 420 stainless insert runs about 9.6 °C hotter than P20 and about 24 °C hotter than aluminum in this example. Closer channels (smaller s) or copper-alloy inserts recover the difference.
Common mistakes
Specifying the class but not the steel. "Class 103 mold" tells a moldmaker the hardness floor, not whether you need stainless, ESR cleanliness or hardened gate inserts. Name the cavity, core and insert materials and their hardness in the specification.
Running glass-filled resin in soft steel without inserts. A prehardened P20 cavity is rated for the cycle count, but at the gate a 30 % glass grade wears the land and opens the gate dimension long before that count. If the main steel is prehardened, make the gate, the shut-offs and any core pin under about 3 mm diameter hardened replaceable inserts.
Through-hardening a huge block. A large H13 or 420 block quenched to 50 HRC can distort, crack at sharp internal corners, or end up softer in the middle than at the surface. For big molds, a prehardened block (P20+Ni or prehardened 420) with hardened inserts where the wear is is usually safer.
Choosing stainless for every mold "to be safe". 420 types conduct heat about a third less well than P20, are slower to machine, and hardened ESR grades need heat treatment and a stress-relief plan. If the resin is not corrosive and the storage is dry, P20 with good rust prevention cools faster and builds faster.
Expecting a mirror from P20. P20's inclusions and roughly 30 HRC hardness limit the final polish, and pits appear under diamond buffing. If the drawing calls SPI A1, the cavity must be ESR steel at about 50 HRC; decide that before the steel is ordered, not at polishing.
Mixing steels without checking galling and expansion. Sliding pairs of the same steel at the same hardness gall. Run slides on wear plates or give mating parts a hardness difference, and remember that an aluminum insert in a steel frame grows about twice as much with temperature.
Forgetting weld repair. Late design changes are often made by welding and re-cutting. Prehardened P20 and aluminum are easy to modify; hardened H13 and 420 need matched filler, preheat and post-weld treatment, and a weld can show through chemical texture or a high polish.
When to use this selector, and when to use something else
Use this selector at the request-for-quote stage, after you know the mold class and the resin grade and before moldmakers propose steel. Putting the steel on the request means competing offers describe the same tool. It is also a quick check on an offer you already have: aluminum cavities for a 300,000-cycle glass-filled job, or plain P20 for a PVC part, will show up as excluded or conditional at once.
Use the mold class selector first if you do not yet know the class; the class sets the hardness floor that drives the first filter here. Use the mold cost-driver estimator to see how material choice interacts with cavities, slides and finish, and the cycle time calculator to turn this page's ΔT into seconds.
Do not use this selector for die casting dies, extrusion dies or compression molds for thermosets: their thermal loads and wear mechanisms differ, and hot-work steel choice for die casting follows different rules. For a mold you will own for years, read aluminum vs steel tooling and how to protect your tooling over time.
Figure 3. The selector's logic. Steps 1 to 5 are hard filters or conditions; only step 6 is a weighted judgment, and its weights and ratings are printed with every result.
Design and sourcing tips specific to mold steel
Put the wear where you can replace it. Gates, shut-offs, thin cores and slide faces wear first. Make them separate inserts in a harder steel than the cavity, and order spares of the fastest-wearing ones with the mold.
Use P20+Ni for large prehardened blocks. Standard P20 can be noticeably softer in the center of a very thick block; nickel-alloyed P20 (1.2738) holds its hardness through larger sections. Ask for the hardness at depth if the cavity is deep.
Specify ESR when polish or texture matters. Electro-slag remelting removes inclusions that show as pits in a mirror polish and as uneven spots in chemical texture. It is worth specifying for A1/A2 finishes, optical parts and large textured show surfaces.
Match the core and cavity thinking. The core usually runs hotter than the cavity because it is surrounded by plastic and harder to cool. A core in a higher-conductivity material, or with baffles, bubblers or a copper-alloy insert, often shortens the cycle more than any cavity change.
Plan corrosion protection even in P20. Purge and spray the mold at the end of every run, keep coolant treated, and store in a dry place. A rusted cooling channel reduces flow, raises the cavity surface temperature and lengthens the cycle quietly.
Decide on texture before hardening. Chemical texture is applied after the final machining. Weld repairs, different steel batches and different hardness across inserts can all etch differently, so keep one steel and one hardness across any show surface that is textured.
Record the steel and hardness on the mold drawing. When the tool needs repair years later, the welder needs to know the grade and hardness to choose filler and heat treatment.
Limits of this selector
The hardness floors follow the SPI customer guidelines for mold classification. The 1-to-5 ratings and the weights are this page's own ordinal summary of commonly published grade characteristics; they are a transparent starting point, not a material test, and steel makers' branded grades within each family differ. The thermal check is a one-dimensional, time-averaged estimate that ignores channel spacing, contact resistance at inserts and transient peaks. The tool does not cover hot-runner components, mold base plate steels, copper-alloy inserts, surface treatments such as nitriding or PVD coatings, or die casting dies.
Sources and method
Hardness floors by class: SPI customer guidelines for mold classification, Class 101 to 105 (Society of the Plastics Industry, now the PLASTICS Industry Association). Steel designations: AISI/SAE tool steel types (P20, H13, 420, D2) and the common European material numbers. Brinell–Rockwell conversion: standard hardness conversion tables for steel (ASTM E140). SPI surface finish grades A1 to D3: SPI mold finish guide. Conduction: Fourier's law for steady one-dimensional conduction, ΔT = q·s ÷ k, applied to the time-averaged heat released by the part. Conductivity values: representative room-temperature values from steel and aluminum producers' published datasheets, rounded.
Questions and answers
Which steel is best for an injection mold?
There is no single best mold steel; the right one depends on the cycle life, the resin and the finish. For most medium-volume molds in unfilled, non-corrosive resin, prehardened P20 type steel at about 30 HRC is the default because it is machined in the hardened state and needs no heat treatment. For more than about 500,000 cycles, glass-filled resin or high-polish parts, through-hardened H13 or 420 ESR stainless at 48 to 52 HRC is used. For corrosive resins such as PVC, a 420 type stainless is preferred. For low-volume or prototype molds, 7075 aluminum mold plate is common.
What is the difference between P20 and H13 mold steel?
P20 is a prehardened plastic mold steel supplied at about 29 to 33 HRC, so it is machined directly into a mold with no heat treatment. H13 is a 5 % chromium hot-work tool steel that is machined soft and then through-hardened, typically to 48 to 52 HRC for plastic molds. H13 resists wear, polishes better and is much tougher at high hardness, so it suits Class 101 and 102 molds and glass-filled resins. P20 is faster to build and easier to modify, so it suits Class 103 molds in unfilled resins.
When do I need stainless steel for a plastic mold?
Use a 420 type stainless mold steel when the resin releases corrosive gases, for example PVC and halogenated flame-retardant grades, when the mold runs cold with condensation, when it will be stored in humid conditions, or when you need a mirror finish that must not pit. Prehardened 420 at about 30 to 34 HRC suits medium volumes; through-hardened 420 ESR at 48 to 52 HRC suits high volumes and optical finishes. The trade-off is lower thermal conductivity, roughly 20 W/m·K against about 30 for P20, which slows cooling slightly.
Can I use an aluminum mold for production?
For low volumes, yes. The SPI guideline allows aluminum cavities in Class 104 molds, meaning under 100,000 cycles in non-abrasive resin, and in Class 105 prototype molds. 7075 aluminum mold plate conducts heat about four times better than P20, so it cools fast, and it machines quickly. It is soft, about 150 Brinell, so glass-filled resins, high clamp loads and repeated parting-line contact wear it quickly, and it cannot reach an SPI A1 or A2 mirror finish reliably. See aluminum vs steel tooling.
Which mold steel should I use for glass-filled plastic?
Glass and mineral fillers erode gates, shut-offs and thin cores. Use through-hardened steel at 48 HRC or above, such as H13 or 420 ESR stainless, for the cavities and cores, or at minimum a prehardened P20 type mold with hardened gate and shut-off inserts. For heavily filled resins above about 30 % glass, a high-wear cold-work steel such as D2 at 58 to 60 HRC is often used for gate inserts only, because it is too brittle for whole cavities.
Which mold steel gives an SPI A1 mirror finish?
An SPI A1 or A2 finish needs a clean, fine-grained steel at high hardness. Electro-slag remelted (ESR) 420 stainless at 48 to 52 HRC is the usual choice for optical and clear parts; ESR grade H13 at the same hardness also polishes well. Prehardened P20 normally reaches about A2 to A3 with careful polishing because its inclusions and lower hardness limit the final polish, and aluminum is not used for A1 or A2 finishes.
Does mold steel affect cycle time?
Yes, through thermal conductivity. Heat from the part must pass through the steel to the cooling channel, and the average temperature drop across that steel is ΔT = q × s ÷ k. For a 2.5 mm glass-filled nylon wall that releases about 578 kJ/m² per mold half over a 10 s cooling time, with 10 mm of steel to the channel, the drop is about 4.4 °C in 7075 aluminum (k 130), 19.3 °C in P20 (k 30), 23.1 °C in H13 (k 25) and 28.9 °C in 420 stainless (k 20). A hotter cavity surface lengthens cooling, which you can offset by placing channels closer or using copper-alloy inserts at hot spots.
Ask JCH about mold steel
Torn between H13 and hardened stainless, or wondering whether hardened gate inserts in a P20 mold would do? Ask our AI assistant. It answers from this website, and our tooling team follows up if you want.
AI assistant. Answers can be wrong; nothing it says is a quote or a promise.
This selector gives an engineering estimate. Our tooling team reviews the resin, finish, cycle class and part geometry against the steels on your request for quote, and flags where hardened inserts, stainless cavities or a different core material would serve the program better.