Answers › FMEA and control plan

FMEA and control plan for a molded part: what each one covers and how they connect

Reviewed by the JCH tooling team · Updated

An FMEA lists how a part design (DFMEA) or its production process (PFMEA) could fail, what each failure would cause, and which controls prevent or catch it. The control plan then turns the PFMEA's chosen controls into the checks, frequencies and reaction plans run on the molding floor.

The method most automotive customers now point to is the AIAG and VDA FMEA Handbook. Umbrex dates it to June 2019, and AIAG still sells it as a first edition; the current printing folds in the published errata and, in AIAG's words, adds no new FMEA content. The handbook merged the separate AIAG and VDA approaches into one seven-step method and replaced the Risk Priority Number with Action Priority.

Buyer education, not a quality-system claim. This page summarises public sources for people who buy molded parts. It does not reproduce the handbook's text or rating tables, which AIAG sells, and it says plainly where the sources disagree.

Where the two documents sit in a molded-part program

On automotive programs, both documents are part of the Production Part Approval Process (PPAP). Ford's PPAP requirements, written for the AIAG PPAP Fourth Edition, number them as elements: the design FMEA at 2.2.4, required "if the organization is product design-responsible", the process flow diagram at 2.2.5, the process FMEA at 2.2.6 and the control plan at 2.2.7. The automotive molding and PPAP note covers the full package; this page covers how the FMEA and the control plan are built and how to read them.

AIAG's product page describes the handbook as a guide to three kinds of analysis: Design FMEA, Process FMEA, and a Supplemental FMEA for Monitoring and System Response. For a molded part with no electronics in it, the first two are the ones a buyer will normally be shown.

DFMEA or PFMEA: who writes which, and what each covers

Umbrex draws the line simply: a design FMEA examines potential design-related failures, a process FMEA examines manufacturing-process failures, and neither one replaces the other. On a molded part, the split usually follows design responsibility. Ford asks a supplier for a DFMEA only when the supplier is design-responsible. A build-to-print supplier instead obtains the customer's DFMEA information, including potential critical and significant characteristics, and uses it to develop the PFMEA. So a buyer who owns the part design, or pays a design firm for it, also owns the DFMEA question. The molder owns the PFMEA.

DFMEA (design)PFMEA (process)
The question it asksCould the part fail in use even if it is made exactly to the drawing?Could the molding process make a part that misses the drawing?
Typical molded-part contentWall thickness, rib and boss proportions, draft, resin grade, fits, snap and screw loadsResin drying, mold temperature, fill and pack, gates and vents, ejection, degating and trimming, inspection, packing
Usually written byThe design ownerThe molder, with input from the toolmaker
When to startBefore the design is frozen for toolingBefore production tool steel is cut

The PFMEA timing in the last row comes from the Astemo Americas supplier manual, a Tier 1 automotive supplier's requirements for its own suppliers. It says the PFMEA "should be initiated before production tooling is started to allow the incorporation of preventive measures into the tooling and the process." For molding, that timing carries more weight than for most processes. A cooling circuit, an ejector layout or a gate moved to another face costs little to add while the mold is still a design and a great deal once the steel is cut; see changing a mold after it is built. The same manual adds that the PFMEA "should not rely on product design changes to correct weaknesses in the process."

Clear molded cover being lifted off the polished core of an open injection mold, with the press tie bars above and below
A clear molded cover coming off the polished core of an open mold, between the press tie bars. Every feature that steel forms is a place where the process FMEA asks what the molding could get wrong, and where the control plan has to say how it is checked.

The seven steps, applied to one molded part

Omnex, whose author is listed as a writing member of the handbook's first edition, summarises its seven steps as listed below, and notes that they guide design, process and supplemental FMEAs alike. The right-hand column is our illustration for a molded housing with screw bosses. It is not handbook text.

StepWhat the team does (Omnex, shortened)Molded-housing illustration
1. Planning and preparationDevelop an FMEA project planScope: one part number, one mold, from resin receipt to packed carton
2. Structure analysisDepict the product or process with a graphical or visual methodProcess flow: receive resin, dry, mold, degate and trim, inspect, pack
3. Function analysisIdentify the functions and the requirements used to judge them"Form each boss to full size with the bore on position," judged against the drawing
4. Failure analysisIdentify failure modes, effects of failure and causesCause: resin molded before it was fully dried. Mode: brittle boss. Effect: the boss cracks when the end user drives the screw
5. Risk analysisRate the severity of the effect, the occurrence of the cause and its detectionRate with the handbook's criteria; record prevention and detection controls separately
6. OptimizationDecide which risks need action and define those actionsLog dryer dew point and drying time for each lot; torque-test bosses on first-off parts
7. Results and documentationSummarise findings, risk reductions and the remaining residual riskRelease the PFMEA revision and update the control plan to match

The step 4 example is a real molding trap. Our drying answer explains why a hydrolysed part from wet resin can look perfect and pass a visual check while being weaker than it should be. That is why the illustration pairs a prevention control at the dryer with a functional test, rather than leaning on inspection by eye.

Two habits from Umbrex's guide make a molded-part PFMEA more useful. The first is keeping cause, failure mode and effect apart, so "operator error" is never accepted as a cause; the cause is the specific condition, such as a dryer reading nobody logged. The second is building the structure on three levels: the process item, the process step, and the work elements behind each step. At a molding press, the work elements are the setter, the machine, the mold and the resin, and each one brings its own causes.

Action Priority instead of RPN

The traditional way to rank FMEA risks was the Risk Priority Number, which Wikipedia defines as severity times probability (the occurrence rating) times detection. Umbrex is direct about the change: "AP replaces the traditional Risk Priority Number as the handbook's action-prioritization method; it is not simply a renamed numerical score." Teams rate severity, occurrence and detection with the handbook's criteria and then read High, Medium or Low from its Action Priority tables. Those tables are not reproduced here.

A little arithmetic shows why multiplying three ratings misleads. Take three rows from the molded housing. The ratings below are made up to show the method; they were not read from the handbook's criteria.

RowFailure mode and effectSeverityOccurrenceDetectionRPN = S × O × D
ABoss cracks in use; the housing can come apart92590
BSink mark on a hidden inside face36590
CLight flash on a non-functional edge21010200

Rows A and B both score 90, though one can let a housing come apart in use and the other is a mark nobody sees. Row C outranks both. Under a team rule such as "act on anything over 100", only the flash gets attention and the cracking boss gets none. Action Priority avoids that trap by looking up the three ratings together in the handbook's tables instead of multiplying them. Umbrex adds two cautions worth repeating to any supplier. A Low priority is not a declaration that a process is safe or acceptable. And a better check does not lower the severity: in Umbrex's fictional example, the team keeps severity where it was after improving detection, because severity belongs to the effect, not to the odds of catching it. Note too that a higher detection rating means weaker detection.

Whether an RPN may still appear beside the Action Priority is not settled across sources, and customers differ. Wikipedia lists GM, Ford, Stellantis and several other carmakers as accepting the handbook as of 2024. Ford's PPAP requirements still direct suppliers to the Ford FMEA handbook and say that where a supplier uses the AIAG and VDA handbook, Ford "will accept the use of the format." GM's customer-specific requirements ask for Risk Priority Levels, applied "using Severity, Occurrence, and Detection ranking tables", and record that GM replaced "Risk Priority Number (RPN)" with Risk Priority Levels throughout that document in 2022. Before anyone scores a row, check the edition and the rating method your customer names.

How the control plan follows from the PFMEA

The control plan is where the PFMEA's decisions become routine work on the floor. In Umbrex's words, "Control plans translate selected controls into production practice," and the last FMEA step includes updating the control plans and operating instructions. Ford turns the link into a requirement: "Characteristic traceability is required from the DFMEA through the PFMEA to the Control Plan and to the process instructions." In practice, every special characteristic in the FMEA should reappear as a control plan row that says what is checked, how, on how many parts, how often, and what happens when the check fails.

One PFMEA row for a molded housing, with cause resin not fully dried, failure mode brittle boss and effect boss cracks at screw driving, feeding two control plan rows: dryer dew point and drying time logged each lot with a hold-and-re-dry reaction, and a boss torque test on first-off parts, one per cavity, with a quarantine reaction. From one PFMEA row to two control plan rows (illustration, not the AIAG form) PFMEA row (steps 4 to 6) Process step: mold the housing Cause: resin not fully dried Failure mode: brittle boss Effect: boss cracks when the screw is driven Prevention control: dryer dew point and time logged per lot Detection control: boss torque test on first-off parts Control plan row 1 What: resin dryness before molding How: dryer dew point and time record How often: each lot and each shift If it fails: hold the resin and re-dry Control plan row 2 What: boss strength at screw driving How: torque test fixture How often: first-off, one part per cavity If it fails: quarantine back to last pass

The exact columns come from the form your customer names. Ford asks for control plans "in accordance with the AIAG Control Plan Manual, latest edition", and Astemo accepts its own form or an equivalent AIAG form. What the customer documents quoted here share is the content: what is checked, how, on how many parts and how often, and the reaction plan when a check fails. GM adds that sample sizes and frequencies "shall be determined based on risk, occurrence of failure modes, and volume", which ties them straight back to the PFMEA ratings. The diagram's frequencies are an illustration, not a recommendation for your part.

Control plans also change with the stage of the program, and here the naming is not settled. The Astemo manual asks for a prototype control plan to go with prototype parts and, under its early production containment rules, a pre-launch control plan that is "over and above the Production Control Plan and is used to validate it", ahead of the production control plan itself. AIAG's Control Plan manual is now a standalone first edition, its content having been removed from the third edition of the APQP manual, and AIAG says it introduces a "Safe Launch" requirement to the control plan phases. If your customer names an edition, use its phases. If not, agree the phase names and what changes between them in writing.

One more point from the Astemo manual suits molding directly: a family of parts "produced using a common mold; process, material and location" may share one control plan, subject to the customer's approval. That fits a family mold or a multi-cavity tool, as long as the plan still records which cavity each sample came from.

Worked example: why the sample plan should name the cavity

Suppose the PFMEA flags the boss bore on a four-cavity tool, and the control plan says "5 parts every 2 hours" without naming cavities. The figures are made up for the arithmetic. If the 5 parts are picked at random from mixed output, each part has a 3 in 4 chance of coming from some cavity other than cavity 4.

So with random picks, roughly three checks in four leave some cavity out, and a cavity that starts to drift has about a one in four chance of slipping past each check. A sample plan of one part from each cavity, plus one extra, leaves no cavity out at the same five parts. The customer documents point the same way: Ford's PPAP requirements ask for dimensional results measured "from every cavity", and GM's annual layout rule asks for at least one part per cavity. A buyer can check this in a minute by reading the sample-size column.

What to ask a molder for

Read the answers against your own drawing before the tool is built; the DFM review note covers that review. Two numbers belong in the same file once parts exist. Umbrex notes that measurement system analysis supports confidence in inspection data and statistical process control helps monitor variation, so a gauge study and a capability figure tell you whether the control plan's checks can be trusted; try the gauge R&R calculator and the Cpk calculator. The first production parts are then checked against the plan, as described in the first article inspection note. Carmakers publish their customer-specific requirements on the IATF Global Oversight site, which is where to look up the edition your customer names.

If your part is not automotive

Umbrex says manufacturers outside automotive can adopt the handbook's process-analysis logic but "should not assume that automotive submission requirements automatically apply to their customers or products." A consumer-product brand rarely needs a formal FMEA package in an automotive format. The logic still earns its keep. Name the three or four characteristics that would make the part fail in use, ask how the molding process prevents each one and how a bad part would be caught, and make sure the inspection plan says how often. That is a short version of the same chain, from a PFMEA row to a control plan row, written in plain words. For the inspection side, see quality control and inspection and the pre-shipment inspection checklist; for likely failure causes by defect, the defect troubleshooter is a starting list for brainstorming step 4.

On a JCH program, the quality documents to be delivered, and their format, are whatever that program's written quote lists. This page does not promise any of them.

Common questions

When was the AIAG and VDA FMEA handbook released?

Umbrex dates the harmonised handbook to June 2019. AIAG sells it as a first edition, and its current printing folds in the published errata with, in AIAG's words, no new FMEA content. Check the edition your customer names.

Is the RPN no longer allowed?

Under the 2019 handbook, Action Priority replaces the RPN as the method for ranking actions, according to Umbrex. Whether an RPN may still be shown beside it is not settled across sources, and customer requirements differ: GM, for example, uses Risk Priority Levels in its own requirements. Follow the method your customer names.

Who writes the DFMEA and who writes the PFMEA?

Usually the design owner writes the DFMEA and the molder writes the PFMEA. Ford asks a supplier for a DFMEA only when the supplier is design-responsible; a build-to-print supplier uses the customer's DFMEA information to develop its PFMEA.

How does the control plan relate to the PFMEA?

It turns the controls chosen in the PFMEA into production checks, with a method, sample size, frequency and reaction plan for each characteristic. Ford requires traceability from the DFMEA through the PFMEA to the control plan and the process instructions.

How many control plan phases are there?

That is not settled. The Astemo Americas supplier manual uses prototype, pre-launch and production control plans, and AIAG says its Control Plan first edition adds a Safe Launch requirement to the phases. Use the phases in the edition your customer names, or agree them in writing.

Is an FMEA done once?

No. The Astemo manual calls the PFMEA a living document to be updated each time a new failure mode is identified, and GM's requirements ask for a PFMEA review at least once a year.

Do I need an FMEA if my part is not automotive?

Not as a formal automotive submission. Umbrex says manufacturers outside automotive can use the logic but should not assume automotive submission requirements apply. A short list of the characteristics that matter, with how each is prevented and checked, covers most of the value.

Sources

Summaries and short quotes from the public documents above, checked on November 15, 2026. The AIAG and VDA handbook and the AIAG manuals are sold by AIAG; this page reproduces none of their text or tables.

Have a molded part where a few features must not fail? Send the drawing with those features marked, and we'll go through how each one would be checked before you compare quotes. NDA first if you want one.

Send a part for reviewBook a 30-minute call

Ask JCH about FMEA and control plans

Have a question about FMEA and control plans? Ask our AI assistant. It answers from this website, and our tooling team follows up if you want.

AI assistant. Answers can be wrong; nothing it says is a quote or a promise.