Choose acrylic (PMMA) when the part must be the clearest, hardest-surfaced and most sun-stable, and will not be dropped, flexed or screwed down hard. Choose polycarbonate when it must survive impact or heat, and plan for a hard coat, a UV-stabilized grade and low molded-in stress. Shrink, mold temperature, drying and annealing all change with the choice.
Acrylic (polymethyl methacrylate, PMMA) and polycarbonate (PC) are the two resins most clear parts end up in, and they are close to mirror images of each other. Acrylic is the clearer, harder and more sun-stable of the pair, but it breaks like glass when it is hit, flexed or screwed down too hard. Polycarbonate bends and dents instead of breaking and holds its shape at higher temperatures, but its surface marks easily and it is notorious for cracking when the wrong chemical meets a stressed area.
So the real question is which failure your part can live with: a cracked acrylic lens after a drop, or a scuffed, crazed polycarbonate cover after a year of cleaning. For other clear resins and the defects every clear part fights, see molding clear and transparent parts.
Every number below comes from the datasheet of one named grade. Two are polycarbonate molding grades and two are acrylic molding grades. Makrolon 2407 and PLEXIGLAS 8N are tested to ISO methods; LEXAN 141 and Plexiglas V825 are tested to ASTM methods, which is what makes the impact and hardness rows comparable between them.
| Property | PC: Makrolon 2407 (ISO) | PC: LEXAN 141 (ASTM) | PMMA: PLEXIGLAS 8N (ISO) | PMMA: Plexiglas V825 (ASTM) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Light transmission | 88% at 3 mm, 89% at 2 mm | 88.0% at 2.54 mm | 92.0% (ISO 13468-2, thickness not stated) | 92.0% at 3.18 mm |
| Haze | below 0.8% at 3 mm | 1.00% at 2.54 mm | below 0.5% | below 1.0% at 3.18 mm |
| Refractive index | 1.584 | 1.586 | 1.490 | 1.490 |
| Notched impact, 23 °C | 65 kJ/m² (Izod, ISO 180/A) | 800 J/m (Izod, D256) | not listed; unnotched Charpy 20 kJ/m² | 16 J/m (Izod, D256) |
| Elongation at break | more than 50% | 130% | 5.5% | 6.0% |
| Stiffness | 2,400 MPa tensile | 2,340 MPa flexural | 3,300 MPa tensile | 3,100 MPa tensile |
| Surface hardness | ball indentation 116 N/mm² | Rockwell M70 (R118) | not listed | Rockwell M93 |
| Heat deflection, 1.8 MPa | 124 °C | 132 °C | 98 °C | 102 °C (annealed bars) |
| Vicat softening, 50 N | 145 °C | 154 °C | 108 °C | 104 °C |
| Molding shrinkage | 0.65% with flow, 0.70% across (2 mm plaque) | 0.50 to 0.70% (3.2 mm) | not listed | 0.20 to 0.60% with flow |
| Drying before molding | 120 °C, 2 to 3 h, to 0.02% max. | 120 °C, 3 to 4 h, to 0.020% max. | below 98 °C, 2 to 3 h | 88 to 93 °C, 4 h, to 0.10% max. |
| Melt temperature | 280 to 320 °C | 295 to 315 °C | 220 to 260 °C | below 271 °C |
| Mold temperature | 80 to 120 °C | 70 to 95 °C | 60 to 90 °C | 66 to 93 °C |
| Vent depth | 0.025 to 0.075 mm | 0.025 to 0.076 mm | not listed | 0.051 mm |
| Sunlight | sold as UV-stabilized | not described as UV-stabilized | “very good weather resistance” | “excellent weatherability” |
Three rows decide most projects. Impact: on the same ASTM test, the LEXAN grade absorbs 800 J/m and the acrylic 16 J/m, a factor of 50. Clarity: acrylic passes about 92% of light, polycarbonate 88 to 89% at similar thickness. Heat: the polycarbonates deflect at 124 to 132 °C under load, the acrylics at 98 to 102 °C.
Elongation at break tells the same story as impact: the acrylic grades stretch 5.5 to 6% before breaking, the polycarbonates more than 50% (Makrolon) and 130% (LEXAN). Any feature that deflects or carries a local load feels that difference.
If the part will be dropped or used as a guard, polycarbonate is the default. Impact-modified acrylic grades exist; get that grade’s impact, haze and transmission data first.
Rockwell M hardness is 93 for the acrylic and 70 for the polycarbonate in the ASTM pair. In use, a PC lens picks up hairline scuffs from cloths and keys sooner. LEXAN 141 lists a Taber abrasion loss of 10.0 mg after 1,000 cycles with CS-17 wheels; the V825 sheet gives no Taber figure, so the two cannot be compared on that test. Neither of the four datasheets lists pencil hardness, so if your drawing calls one out, get it from the coater or resin supplier as a tested value.
The same difference shows up in the tool. Hubs’ table of SPI finishes rates acrylic “excellent” at A-1, A-2 and A-3, and polycarbonate only “average” at A-1 and “good” at A-2. A-1 is a grade 3 (6000 grit) diamond buff at about 0.012 to 0.025 µm Ra; A-2 is grade 6 (3000 grit) at about 0.025 to 0.05 µm. Read together, acrylic is the resin that repays an A-1 polish, while A-2 is a sensible default on polycarbonate faces unless the optics demand more. For a lens, light guide or display window, specify the polish by face on the drawing, not as one note for the whole cavity; our page on mold surface finish covers how finishes are called out.
Under a 1.8 MPa load, Makrolon 2407 deflects at 124 °C and PLEXIGLAS 8N at 98 °C; at softening (Vicat) the gap is 145 against 108 °C. Heat near a lamp or in a closed car points to polycarbonate. The heat deflection lookup lists other resins if neither is enough.
Sunlight runs the other way. Both acrylic makers describe their grades as weather-resistant, and Protolabs’ comparison of the two notes that polycarbonate yellows outdoors unless a UV-stabilized grade is used. Makrolon 2407 is sold as UV-stabilized; LEXAN 141’s datasheet does not describe it that way. For long outdoor exposure, PC parts usually get a UV-absorbing hard coat as well (next section). UV-resistant plastics for outdoor parts goes through the options by resin.
Datasheets do not show this row. The ASM handbook chapter on environmental stress cracking, written by The Madison Group, states that polycarbonate is “highly susceptible” to it and shows up in failures out of proportion to how much of it is used. Its cases include PC housings cracked by cutting oil on metal fasteners and a handheld monitor housing cracked by sunscreen lotion. It also notes that two liquids that are mild on their own, cyclohexanone and isopropanol, become aggressive to PC when blended.
Acrylic is not immune. The same chapter cites PMMA-coated headlamps cracked by methanol in windshield washer fluid. The ACRYLITE knowledge base puts it bluntly: where molded-in stress exists, a solvent tends to cause crazing. On the other side, Arkema’s V825 datasheet lists good resistance to solutions of inorganic acids, alkalis, aliphatic hydrocarbons such as heptane, and many detergents and cleaners. For both resins, test molded parts, under their real assembly stress, in every cleaner, lubricant, adhesive and skin product they will meet. Per the ASM chapter, a lower melt-flow (higher molecular weight) grade of the same resin generally resists ESC better.
The mechanism and the test methods are on why molded parts crack after cleaners, oils or adhesives, and the resin-by-resin chemical tables are on plastic chemical resistance by resin.

The polycarbonate grades shrink 0.5 to 0.7%; the V825 acrylic 0.20 to 0.60% with flow. On an 80 mm lens that is a few tenths of a millimeter, enough to miss a tight fit (worked through below). Size the cavity for the resin you will run, record the shrink factor on the tool drawing, and use the plastic shrinkage calculator or mold shrinkage by resin for your own dimensions.
Makrolon 2407 asks for 80 to 120 °C mold steel and LEXAN 141 for 70 to 95 °C; the acrylics sit at 60 to 93 °C. The upper end of the PC range is above the boiling point of water at atmospheric pressure, so it needs an oil unit or a pressurized water unit. Melt temperatures differ by about 60 °C (280 to 320 °C for Makrolon, 220 to 260 °C for PLEXIGLAS 8N), so barrel settings and residence time do not transfer between them.
Both are dried, but to different limits. The PC sheets ask for 120 °C and no more than 0.02% moisture at the press; V825 asks for 88 to 93 °C for 4 h and allows up to 0.10%, and PLEXIGLAS 8N keeps its dryer below 98 °C. Never dry acrylic at the PC setting: 120 °C is above its Vicat point. Why some plastics must be dried and the resin drying calculator cover dryer sizing.
On a clear part the gate goes where its mark and the flow pattern near it will not be seen. Gate style is compared in our gate types page; size it with the gate size calculator. The resin difference is at degating. ACRYLITE’s guidance is that gating and degating methods should be chosen so the part sees the least stress. An acrylic part twisted off a runner by hand, or a sub-gate that shears through a stiff section, can leave a crack or a stressed zone that crazes later.
Vent depths on the datasheets are 0.025 to 0.075 mm for Makrolon 2407, 0.025 to 0.076 mm for LEXAN 141 and 0.051 mm for V825. Trapped gas burns a mark that shows plainly through a clear part, and V825 is run at a fast injection rate. Vent layout is covered in our venting page, with depths by resin in the vent depth guide.
Ejector marks show through a clear part, so pins go on ribs, bosses or flanges where possible. Acrylic’s 6% elongation means it cannot be stripped off an undercut and will crack if a pin pushes a part that is sticking; polycarbonate will whiten (stress-blush) instead. Ejector pin marks has the layout rules.
Under polarized light, molded-in stress shows as rainbow fringes (birefringence). A University of Akron study of glassy polymers reports that polycarbonate’s stress-optical coefficient is about 17 times that of PMMA, which shows little stress-induced birefringence. The same molded-in stress that is invisible in an acrylic light guide can show as colored bands in a PC one, and over a polarizing display those bands reach the end user.
Annealing removes much of that stress. For polycarbonate, Michael Sepe in Plastics Technology gives annealing temperatures of 121 to 135 °C, a heating rate of no more than 50 °C per hour, and cooling no faster than 25 °C per hour until the parts are down to 60 to 65 °C; the most common failure is cooling too fast. The pass test for PC is a solvent dip in an n-propanol and toluene mixture. For acrylic, the ACRYLITE notes say to run the mold as hot as possible and, when needed, anneal in a forced-air oven 20 °F (11 °C) below the grade’s heat distortion temperature.
A hard coat is a thin cured layer that adds scratch and chemical resistance, and for exterior PC carries UV absorber. Coatings of this kind are sold for PC headlamp lenses and glazing, and they are how a polycarbonate part closes most of its scratch gap with acrylic. Momentive’s SilFORT AS4700 system is a typical example: a thermally cured two-layer coat, with a primer applied 1.2 to 4 µm thick and the hard coat 4 to 8 µm (12 µm maximum), and the datasheet recommends a cleanroom for a particle-free surface. Its listed thinners include alcohols and ketones, which is one more reason to keep molded-in stress low on any part that will be coated.
For the tool, the coater needs a racking point off the cosmetic faces, and the coating thickness adds to tight fits, so decide coated or uncoated before the design is frozen. Acrylic can be hard-coated too, but indoors the case is weaker.
A hypothetical flat display window, 80.00 mm long and 2 mm thick, polished both sides, will sit in a housing with a ±0.10 mm length tolerance. Three checks with the numbers above.
1. How much light can get through? At each air-to-plastic surface, light reflects by the fraction R = ((n − 1) / (n + 1))². For acrylic, n = 1.490: R = (0.490 / 2.490)² = 0.0387, or 3.9% per surface. For PC, n = 1.584: R = (0.584 / 2.584)² = 0.0511, or 5.1%. With two faces and the internal re-reflections included, the most that can pass is (1 − R) / (1 + R): 0.9613 / 1.0387 = 92.5% for acrylic and 0.9489 / 1.0511 = 90.3% for PC, before any absorption. The datasheets report 92.0% for the acrylics and 89% at 2 mm for Makrolon 2407, so nearly all of polycarbonate’s gap is surface reflection set by its refractive index. A cleaner PC grade will not close it; an anti-reflective coating could.
2. What does a resin swap do to size? Cut the cavity for Makrolon 2407 at its 0.65% flow-direction shrink: 80.00 / (1 − 0.0065) = 80.52 mm. Mold V825 acrylic in that cavity at 0.20 to 0.60% and the part comes out 80.52 × 0.998 = 80.36 mm to 80.52 × 0.994 = 80.04 mm. That is 0.04 to 0.36 mm long, mostly outside ±0.10 mm. Going the other way, a cavity cut for acrylic at 0.40% (80.00 / 0.996 = 80.32 mm) gives PC parts of 80.32 × 0.9935 = 79.80 mm to 80.32 × 0.993 = 79.76 mm, about 0.20 to 0.24 mm short. Opening a cavity up removes steel, so it is possible, but it means re-polishing.
3. What oven profile does each need? Taking the 1.8 MPa heat deflection of PLEXIGLAS 8N, 98 °C, and the ACRYLITE rule of 11 °C below it gives about 87 °C for the acrylic window. For the PC window, Sepe’s 121 to 135 °C applies; cooling from 130 °C to 65 °C at no more than 25 °C per hour takes at least (130 − 65) / 25 = 2.6 h. Note that the PC annealing range is above the acrylic’s Vicat point of 108 °C, so one oven recipe cannot serve both resins.
Result: behind a polarizing display, wiped often and shielded from impact, acrylic wins. As the outer face of a handheld that gets dropped, hard-coated polycarbonate is safer, with cavity, dryer and oven set up for PC from the start.

JCH works through vetted partner factories that run clear parts. Send the part file, the grade you are considering and the list of chemicals it will meet, and we will check the resin choice and the tool details before steel is cut. If neither resin fits, the ABS vs PC vs PP comparison and the plastic material selector are the next places to look.
Acrylic. PLEXIGLAS 8N and Plexiglas V825 list 92.0% light transmission; Makrolon 2407 lists 88 to 89% at 2 to 3 mm and LEXAN 141 88.0%. Most of the gap comes from polycarbonate's higher refractive index (1.584 against 1.490), which reflects more light at each surface, so an anti-reflective coating narrows it more than a different PC grade would.
On the same ASTM D256 notched Izod test, LEXAN 141 polycarbonate absorbs 800 J/m and Plexiglas V825 acrylic 16 J/m, about 50 times more. Elongation at break is 130% against 6%. Polycarbonate dents or whitens where acrylic cracks, which is why guards, handheld covers and anything that may be dropped usually go to PC.
Most likely environmental stress cracking: a chemical such as an alcohol blend, oil, lotion or threadlocker attacking an area already under molded-in or assembly stress. Polycarbonate is especially prone to it. Fixes are lower molded-in stress (hotter mold, annealing), removing assembly strain at bosses and fits, a hard coat, or a cleaner the resin tolerates.
Often. Its surface is softer than acrylic (Rockwell M70 against M93 in the grades compared here), so uncoated PC lenses and windows scuff in use. Exterior PC usually gets a hard coat with UV absorber, such as a two-layer silicone system about 5 to 12 micrometers thick in total. Indoor parts that are rarely touched may not need one.
Send the part file and the quantity you expect to run, and we'll review it before you commit to tooling. NDA first if you want one.
Send a part for reviewBook a 30-minute call