From SBIR Phase II to production tooling: a path for hardware startups
Short answer: Treat the end of Phase II as a design freeze, not a production start. Run a DFM review before steel, choose a bridge or production tool by volume and how much the design may still change, freeze the design, then prove the tool, the process and the supply chain with a pilot run before the first production order.
Filed under Molds and tooling
Phase II prototypes are usually machined or printed, built to prove the technology. Production parts have to be molded, inspected and repeated. The gap between the two is where hardware programs lose time and money, mostly by cutting steel on a design that is still changing.
What the award covers is set by your agency
Each participating federal agency runs its own SBIR program within guidelines set by Congress, so whether and how award money can be spent on tooling depends on your award terms and your agency. Read them and ask your program officer before you plan tooling spend. JCH does not advise on SBIR rules.
DFM before steel
A part designed to be machined or printed often cannot be molded as drawn. Draft, even walls, rib and boss proportions, and realistic tolerances all have to be designed in. A DFM review before the tool is ordered is the cheapest point to find those problems.
Bridge tooling vs production tooling
| Bridge tooling | Production tooling | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Parts in production material while the design or demand is still settling | Long-run, repeatable production |
| Typical construction | Often aluminum or softer steel, simpler actions | Hardened steel, built for the expected tool life |
| Tool life | Shorter | Longer, set by the mold class specified |
| Design changes | Easier and cheaper to modify | Costly; a change means changing hardened steel |
| Where it fits | Pilot runs, early customers, a design that may still change | A frozen design with forecast volume |
Freeze the design
- Freeze geometry, resin grade, color, tolerances and the critical-to-function features.
- Write down what is still allowed to change, and who approves a change.
- After the freeze, every change goes through change control, because it now means changing steel.
Pilot runs
A pilot run makes a small lot on the production tool and process, then pushes it through assembly, packaging and the inspection plan. It shows yield, assembly problems and packaging damage while fixes are still small. Fix what it finds before the first volume order.
Paperwork worth keeping
Written mold ownership, a mold record and the first article report all help when investors, customers or agency buyers ask how the product is made and who controls the tooling.
Straight answers
Can SBIR Phase II funding pay for production tooling?
That depends on your agency and your award terms. Check them and ask your program officer before planning tooling spend.
Should a hardware startup use bridge tooling?
Often, when the design may still change or demand is uncertain. A bridge tool gets parts in production material without committing to hardened steel.
When should we freeze the design?
Before production steel is cut, after DFM review and testing of parts in the production material.
What is a pilot run?
A small lot made on the production tool and process, pushed through assembly, packaging and inspection to find problems before volume.
How does JCH work with hardware startups?
Any team can send a part file for a free DFM review. Tooling and production are quoted per program and made at vetted partner factories.
JCH is a trade name of WJH & JCH Global Trading LLC. Jack works with vetted partner factories and does not own the plants.
How this note was made: researched and drafted with AI assistance, checked against the sources listed below and edited by the JCH engineering team.
Sources
- About SBIR and STTR - SBIR.gov
- Know The Different Types of Tooling: Prototype, Bridge, and Production - Thogus
- Injection Molding Tools Compared: Soft, Bridge, and Production Tooling - NICE Rapid
- Injection Molding Basics: An Intro to Designing Plastic Parts - Protolabs
- Design for Manufacturability (DFM) in Injection Molding - RJC Mold